A den of thieves – LinkedIn’s copyright infringement handling is abysmal

SUMMARY:

Copyright infringement is rife on the Internet but when the platform upon which stolen content appears seems incapable of knowing its left from its right hand, then it’s frustrating all the way around.

stolen content LinkedInCopyright infringement is almost always a fraught area but when it comes to blatant content theft then the solution should be simple. Not, it seems, in LinkedIn’s case.

Two days ago, I was alerted to the fact that one of our stories had been republished under the name of this content thief on LinkedIn. As you might expect, I socialized the issue on Twitter and friends started piling in on LinkedIn. See image to the right. It’s a tad fuzzy but this comment is typical of those posted:

Content theft is a very unattractive and unimaginative thing to do. Take this down.

I posted up the following comment to the stolen article

This is a direct copy of our content which is subject to our copyright. Please remove it IMMEDIATELY.

That got no reply. Neither have any of the other comments. Is this guy even real?

Colleagues suggested that I report the profile and notify LinkedIn about the copyright infringement which I, along with others, duly did. Apart from the boilerplate response, @LinkedInHelp posted this – a day later.

And today? Another person on the LinkedIn Help Twitter account posts this:


We’re long past that point.

stolen contentWhat is even more astonishing though is that eight people claim to have liked the stolen story – including someone from SAP and another person from IBM. (See the image on the right) Did they actually read the story? Did they not realize the entire thing was a lift from our site? Could they not see this is clearly fake content?

Oh yes – and one other person’s like comes from an account that also steals content!

As an additional check at my end, I clicked through on other stories the thief claimed to have written. They’re ALL stolen. I questioned whether this account is real but then this stolen story has been edited to remove the following text:

This article was created in partnership with Alibaba Cloud. Thank you for supporting the partners who make SitePoint possible.

This thief definitely knows what they’re doing.

Not only is ours and other people’s copyright infringed, but that LinkedIn’s performance so far in attending to this issue is abysmal.

It cannot be beyond the wit of LinkedIn to coordinate among its own people on issues like this but apparently not. And as for 2-3 business days to respond? I’d give any organization 24 hours but this?

Like it or not, LinkedIn is a media organization and as such has important responsibilities when it comes to topics such as copyright infringement. The fact this is occurring should not be a surprise but the difficulties involved in getting a company to act are all too often frustrating. As one person pointed out to me – this is the penalty you pay for a free service where there is no-one to call.

Endnote – as at the time of publishing this story, LinkedIn has not sent an update and the stolen content is still live. If you’d prefer to read the original then it is here.

Postscript: Finally (3rd Aug, 2018) – LinkedIn acted – result?

linkedin help acts

Image credit - via the author

    1. If there was only a way to to generate a hashed key of the copyrighted page and save it on blockchain for digital verification by LinkedIn. Similar to how YouTube handles copyrighted music videos and automatic takedowns. As well as automatic payments to a few big publishers.

    2. says:

      Personally, I love to see stuff like this. It just adds fuel to the fire that started at Facebook and hopefully spreads to other platforms like LinkedIn who have become mind-numbing, algorithm-driven news and content providers. The more that fire burns, the more likely that we can one day return to human curated content rather than machine curated content, where maybe once again personal reputation will matter more than the sophistication of the machine learning algorithm that feeds the “morphine drip news feed”. No faceless newsfeed on Diginomica. The personalities are front-and-center. And that’s why I come here.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *